The 7 Best Sesame Street Toys of 2019

These familiar faces make playtime even more fun

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

First Look

Best Overall: Sesame Street Talking ABC Elmo Figure at Amazon

“The take-along friend every little Sesame Street fan will adore.”

Best Budget: Sesame Street Playskool Collector Pack at Amazon

“There are endless possibilities with these character toys.”

Best for Babies: Big Bird Take Along Stuffed Animal at Amazon

“His features are embroidered on, so there are no worries about loose eyes.”

Best for Toddlers: Feed Me Cookie Monster at Amazon

He responds with sounds, shakes, and phrases.”

Best Stuffed Toy: Peek A Boo Elmo at Amazon

“A realistic representation of the TV character.”

Best Learning Toy: Elmo's On the Go Letter at Amazon

“It makes a great travel toy.”

Best Active Toy: Elmo School Bus Ride-On at Amazon

“Features flashing lights, lively music, and realistic engine sounds.”

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Sesame Street Talking ABC Elmo Figure

This talking Elmo doll tops our list for oh so many reasons. First of all, it’s Elmo, and what’s not to love about this adorable, red monster? Beyond that, when you push on his tummy, he sings the alphabet, talks and giggles in his own special, recognizable way. He’s the take-along friend every little Sesame Street fan will adore for pretend play. This soft, huggable Elmo stands 13 inches tall and runs on two batteries, which aren’t included. He’s recommended for kids ages 18 months to 4 years old.

Looking for more options? Check out the best developmental toys for babies.

Best Budget: Sesame Street Playskool Collector Pack

All their favorite Sesame Street characters come in this one low-priced package of toy figures. There’s Elmo, Grover, Abby Cadabby, Cookie Monster, and even that grumpy, but loveable grouch, Oscar—a whole gang of friends ready for some awesome pretend play anytime, anywhere. Because there are so many, it's great for keeping kids entertained when they're on their own.

They’re small enough to take on the go and make great toys for the pool, beach, car, or anywhere little ones play. Recommended for ages 18 months and up, parents say kids of all ages love them.

Best for Babies: Big Bird Take Along Stuffed Animal

The tiniest tots will love this soft and sweet Big Bird stuffed animal from Gund. Recommended for ages 1 and up, it makes for cute room decor until they’re on the move and ready to take Big Bird along with them. His features are embroidered on, so there are no worries about loose eyes or other features coming off and creating a choking hazard for little ones who tend to put everything in their mouths. He measures 12.5 inches high, and his arms and legs are soft, floppy, and perfect for snuggling.

If you need more toy ideas for your little one, take a look at the best Lamaze toys for babies.

Best for Toddlers: Feed Me Cookie Monster

He wants a cookie, and a cookie he will get, as toddlers feed the included plastic one into his big, blue, furry mouth. He responds with sounds, shakes and phrases that let you know just how much he likes them. He’ll even sing a song. Cookie Monster measures 13 inches tall, and he requires two AA batteries (only demo batteries are included).

He’s recommended for kids 18 months-4 years of age. Similar to Tickle Me Elmo, this toy is fun, interactive, and a great addition to playtime.

Best Stuffed Toy: Peek A Boo Elmo

It’s hard to get much more adorable than loveable, squeezable Elmo. This plush toy from Gund features everyone’s favorite red monster all nestled below a snuggly blanket, ready to play peek-a-boo. As kids pull the blanket up and down, Elmo responds with one of 13 phrases. Soft and cuddly, he requires three AA batteries, which are included, so he’s ready to go right out of the box. Designed for kids ages 18 months and up, he’s 15 inches tall, which is just the right size for cuddling.

Parents say little ones go crazy for this toy, and that it’s a realistic representation of the TV character. Most find it to be well-made, and while some note the blanket gets stuck from time to time, most say it’s a great choice for kids who love Elmo.

If you're looking for more fun toy ideas, check out the best ride-on toys for toddlers.

Best Learning Toy: Elmo's On the Go Letter

Oh, let us count the ways toddlers will love this set of on-the-go letters. There are at least 26, as it contains all the letters of the alphabet in one handy-dandy carrying case that features Elmo’s sweet face on the front. Each letter fits into its own slot, and beneath are more familiar characters and items that start with each letter.

For example, below “A” is a picture of Abby Cadabby, while “Y” features a yo-yo. It’s a great way for kids to learn the letters and sounds, and as they progress, the letters can be used to create words and promote early reading skills. Recommended for ages 2 to 4, it’s a great way to combine fun and learning.

Best Active Toy: Elmo School Bus Ride-On

For Sesame Street fun on the go, there’s this ride-on school bus, driven by none other than Elmo himself. Beep! Beep! This one features flashing lights, lively music and realistic engine sounds for revved-up fun and learning. Kids power it with their feet while they can turn gears and the steering wheel for imaginative play. It’s recommended for kids ages 12 months to 3 years, and it runs on two AA batteries, which are included.

Our Process

Our writers spent 5 hours researching the best Sesame Street toys on the market. Before making their final recommendations, they considered over 30 different Sesame Street toys to buy overall, screened options from 15-20 different brands and manufacturers, read over 150 user reviews (both positive and negative), and tested 1 of the toys themselves. All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.

Was this page helpful?