The 8 Best Pacifiers for Newborns of 2019

Soothe your baby with the perfect fit

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

First Look

Best Overall Pacifier for Newborns: Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier at Amazon

"Used in many hospitals, they’re BPA- and latex-free and made from one solid piece of hospital-grade silicone."

Best Pacifier for Breastfed Newborns: MAM Pacifiers at Amazon

"It's flattened and extends when the baby sucks on it, much like a human nipple."

Best Pacifier for Newborns With Colic: NUK Newborn Pacifierat Amazon

"Its heart-design helps baby breathe easier, and the nipple is constructed to promote good oral health."

Best Orthodontic Pacifier for Newborns: Chicco NaturalFit Pacifier at Amazon

"The nipple is shaped to make sure the tongue’s pressure against the palate is evenly distributed."

Best Pacifier for Fussy Newborns: The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier at Amazon

"They’re soft and soothing, and many say their babies finally took to these after they tried multiple other options."

Best Dishwasher Safe Pacifier for Newborns: Philips Avent Orthodontic Pacifier at Amazon

"It’s designed with orthodontia in mind."

Best Pacifier for Preemies: Wee Thumbie at Amazon

"It’s recommended for low-birth-weight babies who may still be in the NICU."

Best Design Newborn Pacifier: Doddle & Co. Pop Silicone Pacifier at Pottery Barn Kids

"It’s designed so the nipple pops back into its own protective bubble when it slips from baby’s mouth and onto the dirty floor."

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier

Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier, 0-3 Months, 2-Pack, Pink/Purple

Courtesy of Amazon

Hundreds upon hundreds of customers swear that these pacifiers from Philips AVENT saved their sanity during the newborn months. They credit them with improved sleep for baby (and therefore themselves) and overall happiness.

Used in many hospitals, they’re BPA- and latex-free and made from one solid piece of hospital-grade silicone, which means there aren’t lots of crevices in which dirt and debris can hide, or fear of choking from parts coming apart. They come in six different colors, and they can be sterilized by boiling them for five minutes. Many parents also say they’re great for breastfeeding babies and don’t create nipple confusion. Overall, parents say they’re a great go-to pacifier that most babies love.

Best for Breastfed Newborns: MAM Pacifiers

When you’re breastfeeding, you want a pacifier that is as similar to a mother’s breast as possible, like this one from MAM. The nipple on this pacifier is symmetrical, which means there’s no need for mom or dad to help adjust it, as it’s always a good fit. It's flattened and extends when the baby sucks on it, much like a human nipple.

It comes in a carrying case to keep it clean on the go, and you can sterilize it in that same carrying case by zapping it in the microwave for just three minutes. It’s also designed to not lay flat against baby’s skin, which helps prevent drool from getting trapped in there and irritating baby’s skin. Parents say babies love these pacifiers, calling them a “lifesaver.” They say they stay in baby’s mouth instead of sliding out like others, and that they love how easy they are to sterilize.

Best for Colic: NUK Newborn 100% Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier

While no one knows what causes colic, parents of babies affected by it will say that they’ll try anything to help cure it. Many say these pacifiers from NUK are worth a shot. Its heart-design helps baby breathe easier, and the nipple is constructed to promote good oral health. Made from a single piece of silicone, they’re easy to wash, and you don’t have to worry about water and mold getting stuck in the nipple.

Parents say kids take to them well and that they even seem to help with issues like reflux. Many note that they wish they made them for older children as well.

Best Orthodontic: Chicco NaturalFit Pacifier

Many parents take a hard pass on pacifiers because they’re worried about the effects on their baby’s teeth down the road, but orthodontic pacifiers like this one from Chicco can help ease those concerns. It’s designed with your baby’s oral health in mind at every turn. For example, the nipple is shaped to make sure the tongue’s pressure against the palate is evenly distributed, and its base is narrow so baby can easily close their mouth around it. It also comes in a case in which you can easily sterilize the pacifier by just popping it in the microwave.

Parents say babies love these pacifiers, and as they get older they’re great for teething too. They’re made from one piece of silicone, so they’re easy to clean and you don’t have to worry about them falling apart.

Best for Fussy Newborns: The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier

When baby is fussy, nobody is happy, so finding the right pacifier can be a coup for the whole family. This one from The First Years is the one many parents say was the right find for them. Its one-piece silicone design is similar to that of other popular newborn pacifiers, but it stands out for the nose cutout that makes it easier for some babies to use and breathe easier.

Some customers find them too stiff, but the majority of parents say they’re soft and soothing, and many say their babies finally took to these after they tried multiple other options.

Best Dishwasher Safe: Philips Avent Orthodontic Pacifier

Some pacifiers should be boiled, while others can be sanitized in the microwave, but for many, the easiest thing to do is just pop them in the dishwasher, which is safe to do with this pacifier from Philips Avent. It also comes with a snap-on cap (also dishwasher-safe) to help keep it clean in between washing. It’s designed with orthodontia in mind to help avoid future problems down the line, and the shield has six holes in it to prevent saliva from getting trapped and allowing air to flow.

Parents love these pacifiers and say their babies do, too. They say they’re easy to clean, and they like the ring that makes it easy for baby to grasp the pacifier. They also note they like that there’s no “up” or “down” side, so that it can be popped into baby’s mouth correctly either way.

Best for Preemies: Wee Thumbie

For the tiniest babies, finding a pacifier that’s not too big or overwhelming can be especially challenging, but this one from Philips is designed especially for preemies. It’s designed to replicate the size of a premature baby’s thumb. It’s recommended for low-birth-weight babies who may still be in the NICU, so it has a notched area to allow for feeding tubes and other medical equipment.

Best Design: Doddle & Co. Pop Silicone Pacifier

Doddle & Co. Pop Silicone Pacifier Twin Pack

Courtesy of Pottery Barn Kids

Talk about a parent’s dream come true, this pacifier from Doddle & Co. is designed to keep itself clean. From the hit show Shark Tank, it’s designed so the nipple pops back into its own protective bubble when it slips from baby’s mouth and onto the dirty floor. That doesn’t mean you’ll never have to clean, it, but it will definitely help since those pacifiers drop on the floor a lot.

They come in three pretty colors, and they have a unique look that makes them stand out from other pacifiers. They’re safe to use from birth and beyond, and they’re dishwasher safe, too. This choice may be a bit pricier than some other pacis, but two come in one package so you’ve always got a backup.

Our Process 

Our writers spent 5 hours researching the most popular pacifiers for newborns on the market. Before making their final recommendations, they considered 20 different pacifiers overall, screened options from 15 different brands and manufacturers, read over 150 user reviews (both positive and negative) and tested 1 of the pacifiers. All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.

Was this page helpful?