The 9 Best Nipple Shields

Improve your breastfeeding experience

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Medela Contact Nipple Shield at Amazon

"These shields are specially designed to maximize the amount of skin-to-skin contact between a nursing mother and her baby."

Best Budget: Bonana Silicone Contact Nipple Shield at Amazon

"They act as silicone cushions that stimulate the areola while, at the same time, protecting sore nipples."

Best With Case: purifyou Premium Nipple Shield at Amazon

"With perforated edges for a comfortable fit, these shields—which come in a clear carrying case—can help feeding times go smoother."

Best Full Coverage: Haakaa Nipple Shield at Amazon

"Put space between your nipple and your baby’s mouth, with these unique, bottle-shaped nipple shields."

Best for Flat or Inverted Nipples: NUK Barely There Nipple Shield at Amazon

"These shields have a triangular design with raised ridges around the base that help them stay in place and stimulate milk flow."

Best for Latching Issues: MAM Nipple Shields at Amazon

"Made of soft silicone, these shields are shaped like a pacifier, and have raised dots at the base that stimulate milk flow."

Best for Newborn: Cradle Shell Nippleshield and Breast Shell at Amazon

"This one-two-punch of shells and shields help you get the most out of each and every breastfeeding session."

Best for Problems with Supply: Ardo Medical Tulips Contact Nipple Shields at Amazon

"These thin and pliable nipple shields help correct your baby’s latch, and stimulate your body to produce more milk."

Best for Tongue-Ties: Lansinoh Contact Nipple Shield at Amazon

"These nipple shields are easier for babies with tongue ties to latch onto and protect mom's nipples from an incorrect latch."

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Medela Contact Nipple Shield

nipple shield

Medela

Specially designed to maximize the amount of skin-to-skin contact between a nursing mother and her baby, the Medela Contact Nipple Shields are made from BPA-free, thin silicone. The innovative cut-out shape allows the baby’s nose to make contact with his or her mother’s skin.

Medela Contact Nipple Shields come in three different sizes to accommodate different nipple shapes—16 millimeters, 20 millimeters, and 24 millimeters. Users of the nipple shield should consult a lactation consultant or specialist to determine what size works best for their body.

The soft silicone protects sore breasts and allows breastfeeding to continue with less pain on the part of the mother. Users on Amazon rave that these nipple shields were a lifesaver during the first few months of breastfeeding.  

Best Budget: Bonana Silicone Contact Nipple Shield

Composed of food-grade silicone, the Bonana Silicone Contact Nipple Shield acts as a silicone cushion that stimulates the areola while, at the same time, protecting sore nipples. Four holes at the tip allow for controlled milk flow into the baby’s mouth. These holes also provide air circulation to give relief to cracked or bleeding nipples.

Additional features include a carrying case for storing the product, as well as a range of sizes to fit your nipple. Reviewers on Amazon note that the Bonana nipple shields are very comfortable to use.

Best With Case: purifyou Premium Nipple Shield

It’s late at night and your baby starving—again. The last thing you want to do is root around for a nipple shield you’re not even sure is clean, while the pitches of your baby’s hungry cry become more and more frantic. For that reason, the purifyou Premium nipple shield, which comes with a clear pacifier case, is your best bet.

Made of food-grade silicone, the nipple shields have perforated ridges on the base where the nipple meets the areola, allowing for a comfortable fit. Reviewers note that the purifyou nipple shields are durable, and made a marked improvement in difficult breastfeeding experiences.  

Best Full Coverage: Haakaa Nipple Shield

The patented design of the Haakaa Nipple Shield puts space between your nipple and your baby’s mouth, making it ideal if you are experiencing nipple soreness, or have a baby who bites down while nursing. With a butterfly shape that suctions to your areola, the Haakaa Nipple Shield resembles the nipple on a bottle, and works with all breast sizes. The symmetrical design and anti-slip ridges on the outer edges make the nipple shield easy to hold down while a baby latches.

The nipple itself is designed to allow a consistent, but not too strong, flow of milk and has air holes to prevent gas bubbles from being ingested by a nursing infant—which can lead to colic, among other conditions. Reviewers rave that the Haakaa nipple shield suctioned well to their breasts, and was great for preemies, babies with latch issues, and moms painful nipples alike. 

Best for Flat or Inverted Nipples: NUK Barely There Nipple Shield

One of the difficulties of breastfeeding with flat or inverted nipples is that they don’t stimulate a newborn’s suck reflex as well as a finger, pacifier, or bottle—they just don’t reach the soft palette of a baby’s mouth. That’s why a nipple shield can really aid a breastfeeding mom with small, flat, or inverted nipples.

The NUK Barely There Nipple Shield has a triangular design with raised ridges around the base that both stimulate milk flow and help the nipples to stay in place. Moms with inverted nipples say that hard nipple shields can be difficult to keep in place, but the NUK Barely There Nipple Shield, which is made from soft, pliable silicone, holds suction well. Mothers with large breasts also praised the product.

Best for Latching Issues: MAM Nipple Shields

There are a plethora of reasons why your baby may have difficulties latching, among them the size of his or her mouth relative to your nipple size, a resistance to a strong letdown, or a tongue tie. A nipple shield can really help with latching problems by providing the perfect base for your baby to latch onto, while at the same time regulating the flow of milk.

MAM Nipple Shields are a great product for any and all nipple problems. Made of soft silicone, the Nipple Shields are shaped like a pacifier, and have raised dots at the base that stimulate milk flow. Reviewers say that they preferred MAM to other brands when it came to fixing a problematic latch.

Best for Newborn: Cradle Shell Nippleshield and Breast Shell

The Cradle Shell nipple shield and breast shell set offers two immediate solutions for breastfeeding problems. The two nipple shields, which are made from silicone, help improve latch and protect sensitive nipples. They help ease—and even prevent—the painful cracking and chafing of nipples that often accompanies the first few weeks of breastfeeding. The shields come with a carrying case to keep them clean and make them easier to store.

The breast shells can be worn to collect letdown from the opposite breast of the one you’re nursing on so that none of your milk will go to waste. You can store the collected breastmilk for later, or use it soothe your cracked and dry nipples after breastfeeding.

Best for Problems with Supply: Ardo Medical Tulips Contact Nipple Shields

There are a variety of reasons why your body might not produce enough milk at the beginning of your breastfeeding experience, among them that your baby’s suck isn’t strong enough to signal to your body that it needs to produce milk. The Ardo Medical Tulips Contact Nipple Shields help correct your baby’s latch, and stimulate your body to produce more milk.

The nipple shields come in two sizes—20 millimeters and 24 millimeters—to fit various nipple sizes. Reviewers note that the nipple shield is slightly more pliable than others, allowing your baby to get a more comfortable latch. An added bonus? The nipple shields come with a case so they'll stay clean if you need to toss them into your diaper bag.

Best for Tongue-Ties: Lansinoh Contact Nipple Shield

A tongue-tie is a condition in which a tight band of tissue tethers the bottom of the tongue’s tip to the floor of the mouth, making it difficult for a baby to properly latch onto a nipple while breastfeeding. The latch of babies with tongues ties is unusually shallow, causing immense discomfort and pain for mothers and frustration for babies. Nipple shields are easier for babies with tongue ties to latch onto, and they also protect the mother’s nipple.

Made from soft, flexible silicone, the Lansinoh Contact Nipple Shield has a special cut-out design to maximize skin to skin contact between mother and baby. Mothers who had babies with tongue ties rave that the Lansinoh Contact Nipple Shields feel the closest to not wearing anything at all, and helped moms continue to breastfeed, even when they were ready to give up. 

Was this page helpful?