The 8 Best Nipple Creams of 2020

Ease pumping and nursing pain with these balms, creams, and butters

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Honest Mama Nipple Balm at honest.com

"Safe for both mama and baby, rub on a generous amount, and soak up the moisturizing effects of the coconut oil and shea butter."

Best for Pregnant Moms: Motherlove Nipple Cream at Amazon

"You'll get a lot of use out of this oil-based cream, which has multiple functions as a lip moisturizer and pump lubricant."

Best Lanolin-Based: Lansinoh at Amazon

"100% natural and hypoallergenic to soothe the most sensitive and sore nipples."

Best Non-Greasy Formula: Medela Tender Care Lanolin at Amazon

"A blend of natural, high-performing ingredients, this nipple cream is silky smooth for easy application."

Best for Sensitive Skin: Bella B Nipple Nurture Butter at Amazon

"Free of common irritants and infused with shea butter and antioxidants, it will be your pre and post-breastfeeding staple."

Best Moisturizing: Bamboobies Boob-Ease at Amazon

"Your chest has been through a lot, treat it with this five-ingredient and USDA certified organic formula."

Best Organic: Earth Mama at Amazon

"With its multi-use functionality as a skin moisturizer and nipple butter, you'll want one for the bathroom and nightstand."

Best Handcrafted: Coddle Nipple Balm at coddle.co

"Hand-crafted and travel-sized, Coddle's plant-based balm goes wherever you go in handy, food-grade glass jars."

A new baby brings so many changes to a new mom’s body. Whether pregnant, breastfeeding, pumping or a mix of all three, your nipples are likely getting way more attention than they have in the past. Depending on your situation and body, they can become dry, cracked, chapped, sore, itchy, or even bleeding. 

For some much-needed relief before, during, and after feedings, a soothing nipple cream can make all the difference. For pain and breastfeeding challenges, it can be helpful to enlist the expertise of a lactation specialist, like Ashley Georgakopoulos, International Board Certified Lactation Consultant (IBCLC), and Motif Medical Lactation Director. Ashley says an IBCLC “can help navigate issues or practices that may be contributing to sore, chafed nipples, as well as assist in choosing the right product for your needs as they change!”

Factors that Ashley recommends in a product are:

  • Clean, organic, even food-grade ingredients
  • Portability, something to easily tote around
  • Antifungal ingredients, such as coconut oil
  • Skin-nourishing ingredients, such as calendula, extra virgin olive oil, and vitamin E
  • Consistency for intended use preferences

Ashley says, “Getting in the habit of using a nipple balm while pregnant can help keep the skin supple as well as help protect from issues associated with cracked or damaged skin.”

We've researched the best blams and creams for sore and irritated nipples to help you survive postpartum recovery and breastfeeding your little one.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Honest Mama Nipple Balm

Honest Mama Nipple Balm

 Courtesy of Honest

A natural nipple cream, this balm uses shea butter, beeswax, coconut oil, and other natural 100 percent organic ingredients to soothe tender nipples and alleviate dry skin. It’s safe for both mom and baby, so there’s no need to wipe it off before a feeding. The balm is hypoallergenic, unscented, and made without petrolatum, lanolin, silicones, or synthetic fragrances, so it's soothing for even the most sensitive skin.

If cracked nipples become an issue, the coconut oil lowers the yeast levels on the skin, reducing the risk for thrush, which can become quite painful and disruptive to a good feeding routine. Reviewers praise that it’s not sticky and doesn’t leave a residue, although some find it does have a mild smell.

Best for Pregnant Moms: Motherlove Nipple Cream

Pregnant women may find their nipples becoming tender, dry, or itchy near the end of pregnancy. Look no further than this versatile cream for some relief. The award-winning, 100 percent organic, multi-use formula is a must-have. For breastfeeding moms, the cream is a lifesaver for chapped, itchy nipples.

The unscented, plant-based formulation is not just for nipples; many women use it on chapped lips, dry skin, as a pump lubricant, and more. Reviewers love this product and find a little goes a long way, so the jar will last for a while and it can even be used as a diaper cream for tender baby butts. Since it is oil-based, some note it may stain bras or clothing that it comes in contact with. 

Best Lanolin-Based: Lansinoh

Lanolin is a well-known skin soother made from a wax secreted by sheep that can be extremely helpful and soothing. Pumping mamas may need some extra TLC since the repetitive motion of the pump can make nipples especially sore. This cream is made from thick lanolin that has been purified to ensure a pure hypoallergenic product. A medical-grade product, it’s also useful on dry skin, lips, cuticles, or anywhere else.

In cold temps, the product becomes extremely thick and will need to be squeezed out and rubbed between two fingers to warm it. In warm temperatures, the product can become runny and gooey, so be sure to store it at room temperature with the cap on. If mom is avoiding animal-based products, you’ll want to skip lanolin-based creams.

Best Non-Greasy Formula: Medela Tender Care Lanolin

Medela tender care lanolin

 Courtesy of Medela

Caring for your sore and irritated nursing nipples doesn't have to be messy. The Medela Tender Care lanolin-based cream glides over nipples to create a healing and protective barrier for more comfortable nursing sessions.

Safe for mom and baby, you don't have to worry about wiping it off before feeding your little one. Made of a natural ingredient blend, the mess-free texture makes application a breeze.

Best for Sensitive Skin: Bella B Nipple Nurture Butter

With plant-based and food-grade ingredients, this soothing formulation is free of fragrance and lanolin, which can be an irritant for some women with sensitive skin. The all-natural ingredients include a blend of cocoa, shea, and mango butter that are combined into a soothing cream that can be used before or after feedings to ease sensitive nipples.

Many women find the soft cream much easier to apply than other products and appreciate the tube packaging rather than a tub since it’s a cinch to squeeze out the right amount.

Best Moisturizing: Bamboobies Boob-Ease

For those that appreciate natural products, this formulation is made with olive oil and only four other ingredients. It spreads on very smoothly, without needing to be wiped off prior to feedings. Without lanolin or other synthetic ingredients, Boob-Ease is USDA certified organic.

Reviewers note that the olive oil and coconut-based oil formula can stain clothing or bras, so best to use a washable or disposable nursing pad with this balm. 

Best Organic: Earth Mama

A favorite of hospitals, lactation specialists, and mamas, this lanolin-free, non-sticky, and ultra-moisturizing nipple butter is well-loved for many reasons. This product is the first non-GMO Project Verified nipple cream and doesn’t need to be wiped off before feedings. Many moms appreciate that once this takes up residence on a nightstand, it can be used for dry skin, chapped lips, or even diaper rash. The 2-ounce product will feel like a never-ending tub of skin relief.

Best Handcrafted: Coddle Nipple Balm

Coddle Nipple Balm

 Courtesy of Coddle

Handcrafted in small batches by a Black-owned business, the specially formulated nipple balm is part of their postpartum self-care collection. The soothing balm is made with carnauba wax and other natural ingredients so it’s safe and digestible for babies.

The plant-based, lanolin-free, vegan, and gluten-free formulation is packaged in zero waste food grade jars that are easily recyclable or reusable.

Why Trust Verywell Family

Maya Polton is a former marketing manager and current freelance writer who covers food, home, and parenting. She’s also the mom of a 10-year-old son, 7-year-old son, and 3-year old daughter. When she used nipple cream, she stuck with lanolin products, mostly because she didn’t know how many other great products existed. She was always frustrated that it stained her clothes and still has a favorite nightgown with two oddly placed stains.

Was this page helpful?