The 7 Best Formulas to Buy for Breastfed Babies in 2019

Create a feeding plan that works for your little one

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Breastfeeding your baby provides a host of important health benefits, but it can be difficult and time-consuming as well. Feeding your infant around the clock and worrying about supply issues are just a couple of the obstacles of breastfeeding, to say nothing of the dreaded pump! The demands of life — like returning to work full time, or juggling the schedules of older children — can get in the way of exclusively breastfeeding for the long term. If that’s the case, you might consider supplementing your breastmilk with an infant formula.

When supplementing, you can do whatever works for you; some parents choose to give baby formula overnight so mom can get some rest. Others use formula at daycare but continue breastfeeding at home. In fact, studies show that only 16 percent of moms in the US breastfeed for more than six months.

If you choose to supplement with infant formula, just remember: when it comes to feeding your baby, the best way is the way that works for you and your baby. The key is to find the right formula for his or her unique needs. Here, we’ve come up with a list of several of the top formulas for breastfed babies.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Similac for Supplementation

Similac for Supplementation

Courtesy of Amazon

If you’re breastfeeding and just looking for a bit of a break every now and then, you’ll want to look for the best supplementing formula. A seamless transition between breastmilk and formula is the ultimate goal here. That, and you don’t want baby to suddenly become constipated (remember, since breast milk is easier to digest than formula, baby’s stools are softer when exclusively breastfed).

We found Similac for Supplementation to be the best overall formula for supplementing breastfed babies. Not only is it easy to digest, but it’s packed with crucial pre- and probiotics found in breastmilk. That means your baby’s getting optimal nutrition without suffering from constipation, which is common among formula-fed babies, and one of the biggest complaints of parents searching for an infant formula to supplement with.

Best Budget: Kirkland Signature non-GMO

We love Costco’s products for their high-quality ingredients that often compare to higher priced name-brand products. That’s why we’ve turned to Kirkland Signature non-GMO baby formula for our best budget formula for breastfed babies. This easy-on-the-wallet formula is pretty much identical to Similac’s Pro Advanced formula for a fraction of the price. And when you’re supplementing with formula, it’s best to choose one that has as many of the same ingredients as breastmilk. Kirkland’s formula contains DHA and iron, both important elements for growing brains and bodies.

Best for Gas: Gentlease

All babies have some amount of gas as their tiny bellies grow and expand. But if your breastfed baby is dealing with bad gas, it’s possible he may simply be having a bad reaction to something in your diet. If you’re considering supplementing with formula, turn to one that’ll be super gentle on your baby’s tummy and won’t cause excessive gas.

Our pick is Enfamil Gentlease. It comes with a guarantee that it’s clinically proven to reduce gas and fussiness in as little as 24 hours. Along with a host of healthy vitamins and minerals and brain-boosting DHA, Gentlease contains easy-to-digest proteins to cut down on gas.

Best for Colic: Similac Pro Sensitive

If you’re dealing with a colicky baby, first things first: know that it will get better. Soon this hard phase will be over, and your screaming baby will morph into a sweet, smiling cherub. In the meantime, if you decide to supplement with formula, make the transition easier with Similac Pro Sensitive, one of the best formulas for colicky babies.

Pro Sensitive is formulated with less than 2 percent lactose, a common source of fussiness and colic. It’s also full of elements commonly found in breastmilk, like lutein, vitamin E, and DHA. Many parents who have dealt with colicky babies agree that Pro Sensitive formula was the only solution to their baby’s excessive fussiness and spitting up due to colic.

Best Organic: Plum Organics

Organic baby formula is made with certified organic ingredients, contains no GMOs, and uses milk from cows that weren’t pumped full of antibiotics. So despite a higher price tag for organic formula, it’s hard not to see the benefits. If you’re looking to supplement breastmilk with occasional feedings of organic formula, we recommend Plum Organics Premium Organic formula with iron. It’s the only organic baby formula on the market certified by Oregon Tilth.

Plum Organics formula is 100-percent organic, free of corn syrup solids, uses only lactose from non-rBST cows, and contains DHA and RHA for optimal brain development.

Best for Milk Allergy: Similac Alimentum

One of the biggest reasons moms decide to stop breastfeeding is because of food sensitivities or allergies. If your baby is showing signs of allergies, like excessive fussiness, skin rashes, or blood in her stool, her pediatrician may recommend you try an elimination diet. That means you’ll need to cut dairy out of your diet completely to see if it helps baby’s symptoms. Not up for all that? You could try supplementing with a formula like Similac Alimentum, one of the best formulas for babies with a milk protein allergy.

This top-rated soy-based formula has milk proteins that are broken down into the smallest pieces possible (also called hydrolyzed), which makes this formula one of the easiest for babies to digest. In fact, parents indicate that they’ve seen drastic results in babies who are truly lactose intolerant.

Best for Transitioning to Formula: Enfamil Enspire

If you’ve decided to stop breastfeeding before your baby turns a year old, you’ll need to transition to an infant formula, since it’s not recommended to give cow’s milk to babies under 1. Look no further than Enfamil Enspire for a formula that will provide your baby with the best nutrition. This top-of-the-line formula is Enfamil’s “closest to breastmilk” offering, and to be honest, they’ve hit a home run with Enspire. Parents rave that it doesn’t cause constipation like most other formulas, and it boasts ingredients inspired by breastmilk, like MFGM and lactoferrin.

Our Process

Our writers spent 3 hours researching the most popular formula for breastfed babies on the market. Before making their final recommendations, they considered 16 different formulas overall, screened options from 7 different brands and manufacturers, read over 20 user reviews (both positive and negative), and tested 1 of the formulas themselves. All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.

Was this page helpful?