The 8 Best Crib Sheets of 2019

Keep your little one soft and cozy

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

First Look

Best Overall: American Baby Company Crib Sheet at Amazon

"They feel like your favorite well-worn t-shirt."

Best Budget: Fitted Crib Sheet Floral at Target

"Made of 100 percent cotton, they’re soft, and fit standard cribs."

Best Cotton: Magnolia Organics Crib Sheet at Amazon

"They’re cozy, fit well, and don’t shrink or stretch out after washing."

Best for Babies With Eczema: Burt’s Bees Crib Sheet at Amazon

"They’re designed with the needs of sensitive skin in mind."

Best Cute Pattern: Organic Silly Safari Sheet at Pottery Barn Kids

"These prints will add a pop of personality to any nursery."

Best Soft Sheets: aden + anais Classic Crib Sheet at Amazon

"The fabric is ultra breathable."

Best Organic: Brooklyn Bamboo Organic Crib Sheet at Amazon

"Great for babies with sensitive skin."

Best Zippered: QuickZip Crib Sheet Set at Amazon

"There's no need to remove the entire sheet when it's time to change."

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: American Baby Company Printed Knit Fitted Crib Sheet

American Baby Company 2 Pack Printed 100% Cotton Jersey Knit Fitted Crib Sheet for Standard Crib and Toddler Mattresses

Courtesy of Amazon

For a winning combination of comfort and low cost, hundreds of online reviewers say these sheets from American Baby Company are hard to beat. Made of jersey knit, they feel like your favorite well-worn t-shirt, and they come in a variety of colors and prints. They measure 28 inches x 52 inches x 9 inches and fit most standard crib and toddler mattresses. Customers stay that stains wash right out and that these sheets have a good amount of stretch.

Need a great crib to go with these sheets? Check out the best cribs you can buy today.

Best Budget: Fitted Crib Sheet Floral

Fitted Crib Sheet Floral - Cloud Island™ Pink

Courtesy of Target

The price is right when it comes to these crib sheets from Cloud Island. They come in lots of sweet prints, so you can scoop up several to change the look of the nursery from time to time. Made of 100 percent cotton, they’re soft and fit standard crib mattresses up to 11 inches deep.

Customers rave about these sheets, saying the material is high quality, and the colors keep their vibrancy even after washing. They also love that you can mix and match them with other nursery accessories from this brand.

Best Cotton: Magnolia Organics Fitted Interlock Crib Sheet

For basic crib sheets that are soft and snug-fitting, there are these crib sheets from Magnolia Organics. Made of organic cotton that’s grown without pesticides or other harmful chemicals, they’re good for your baby and the planet, too. They come in a variety of colors and in sizes to fit bassinets and portable cribs.

Customers give these sheets top marks, saying they’re cozy, fit well, and don’t shrink or stretch out after washing. Some customers noted a strange smell when the sheets come out of the package, but most don’t notice it or say it comes right out after the first washing.

Best for Babies With Eczema: Burt’s Bees Fitted Crib Sheet

If your baby has eczema, you want the softest crib sheets you can find, like these from Burt’s Bees Baby. They’re designed with the needs of sensitive skin specifically in mind. Made of 100 percent organic cotton, the jersey knit feels like a well-loved t-shirt. They measure 28 inches x 52 inches and fit most standard cribs and toddler mattresses. They come in a variety of colors and patterns to match any nursery, and parents give these sheets high marks. They say they’re soft, comfortable, and fit securely.

Best Cute Pattern: Organic Silly Safari Crib Fitted Sheet

Organic Silly Safari Crib Fitted Sheet

Courtesy of Pottery Barn Kids

For some of the sweetest crib sheets you’ve ever seen, look no further than Pottery Barn Kids. Picks like this one in their Silly Safari print will add a pop of personality to any nursery. Made of 100 percent organic cotton percale, this 200-thread count sheet is soft and comfortable, too. The sheet has elastic only at the top and bottom for safety, and it will fit a mattress up to 10 inches deep.

If you and your little one are hitting the road soon, take a look at our picks for the best travel cribs.

Best Soft Sheets: aden + anais Classic Crib Sheet

aden + anais Classic Crib Sheet, 100% Cotton Muslin, Super Soft, Breathable, Tailored Snug Fit, up, up + away, elephants

Courtesy of Amazon

Like swaddling blankets, these sheets from aden + anais are made of cotton muslin. The fabric is ultra breathable, meaning it will keep baby cool when the weather is warm, and toasty when it gets chillier. Prewashed, it’s designed to fit cribs up to 52 inches x 28 inches x 8 inches, and it comes in various prints and colors.

Parents say these sheets are downright dreamy. They love the feel and fit and say they wash well and don’t shrink. Many note that they trust the aden + anais brand and say that this sheet lives up the brand’s reputation of high quality, super comfortable baby linens.

Looking for some swaddling blankets, too? Here are our favorite swaddles on the market.

Best Organic: Brooklyn Bamboo Soft Hypoallergenic Organic Bamboo Crib Sheet

Good for your baby and good for the planet, online customers rave about these crib sheets from Brooklyn Bamboo. They’re soft and hypoallergenic, so they’re great for babies with sensitive skin, and they come in several adorable prints.

While some parents wish they fit more snugly, most love them and are blown away by how soft they are. They say they don’t irritate their little one’s skin and that they wash well.

Best Zippered: QuickZip Crib Sheet Set

If you’ve ever struggled to change a wet or soiled crib sheet in the middle of the night with a screaming baby in the background, you’ll love this zippered crib sheet set from QuickZip. The set comes with two pieces—a base that securely wraps around the sides of your crib mattress and then a top piece that zips into the middle of it. When it’s time to change the sheet, there's no need to remove the entire thing, you simply zip off the top part and throw that into the wash and zip on another one (extras are sold separately).

These sheet sets come in a variety of colors and prints and they fit all standard cribs. Parents who have purchased them say they can’t imagine life without them.

Our Process

Our writers spent 5 hours researching the most popular crib sheets on the market. Before making their final recommendations, they considered 25 different sheets overall, screened options from 20 different brands and manufacturers and read over 150 user reviews (both positive and negative). All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.

Was this page helpful?