The 8 Best Baby Baptism Gifts of 2021

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: CompanyTwentySix Personalized Baby Blanket at Etsy

"A perfect addition for baby’s nursery, but it’ll last long past the baby stage!"

Best Budget: Malden May God Bless You Wood Picture Frame at Hallmark

"It’s simple and pretty, with a sizeable 4x6 photo opening."

Best for Boys: Susabellas Personalized Keepsake Round Box at Etsy

"This clay keepsake box is easy to clean and built to last."

Best for Girls: Elle J Maui Rose Gold Newborn Bangle Bracelet at Etsy

"Best baptism gift for baby girls is truly the gift that keeps on giving!"

Best from Grandparents: Baby's First Cross + Engraved Keepsake Box at Personalization Mall

"It comes with a verse of your choice inscribed on the top."

Best from Godparents: Ocean Drop White Muslin Swaddle Blanket for Godchild at Amazon

"Gracefully displays the promise you’re making on their special day."

Best Book: God Bless You and Good Night at Amazon

"Write a special inscription on the inside so they can treasure this book and message for years to come."

Best Art: Baby Animal Sheep at Minted

"Decorate the nursery walls with this adorable sheep art print."

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: CompanyTwentySix Personalized Baby Blanket

The best overall baby baptism gift is one that’s timeless. That’s why we love this embroidered quilt for you to give as a baptism gift. It’s personalizable with baby’s first and middle name along with his or her baptism date. A tiny grey cross sits below the date. A few different choices, like “Baptized in Christ” instead of baby’s name, are also available.

For the monogramming, choose pink for girls and blue for boys, or simply enter your own color choice into the order form. This beautifully soft quilt with scalloped edges will be a perfect addition for baby’s nursery, but it’ll last long past the baby stage!

Best Budget: Malden May God Bless You Wood Picture Frame

A picture frame makes a perfect baby baptism gift. And the good news? You can find beautiful baptism frames without shelling out a ton of money. We love this sweet wooden frame from Hallmark. It’s simple and pretty, with a sizeable 4x6 inch photo opening that allows baby’s parents to include their most precious memory of the day. Inscribed on the frame are the words, “May God bless you today and always.” So if you’re looking for the best budget baby baptism gift, this adorable frame is a great place to start!

Best for Boys: Susabellas Personalized Keepsake Round Box

Personalized Round Keepsake Box — Courtesy of Etsy.

Most baby baptism gifts can be given to either a boy or a girl (they are babies, after all), but we’ve found a sure bet for a gender-neutral gift. It’s an earthenware clay keepsake box in white with a simple logo on top, along with baby’s name. If you’re looking for something that he’ll keep for lots of years, this is a clear winner. Though we can’t guarantee he won’t ever store bugs or worms in there! No worries, though, because this clay keepsake box is easy to clean and built to last. It’s inscribed with either an Irish blessing or whatever thoughts you’d like to share on his special baptism day.

Best for Girls: Elle J Maui Rose Gold Newborn Bangle Bracelet

Newborn Rose Gold Bangle Bracelet — Courtesy of Etsy.

It’s so easy to find the best baptism gift for baby girls—just go with jewelry! Even the youngest lady loves jewelry, after all. There are plenty of options to choose from, but why not opt for this beautiful and tasteful gold bangle for infants. It’s safe for babies to wear, and doesn’t pose any choking or strangulation hazards like jewelry with small beads or dangling parts. And while she’ll grow out of this bracelet before too long, she can still keep it tucked away for the special day when her own daughter is baptized.

Best from Grandparents: Baby's First Cross + Engraved Keepsake Box

It’s a special day to witness your grandchild being baptized. Commemorate the occasion with this beautiful sterling silver keepsake box. It comes with a verse of your choice inscribed on the top, along with baby’s name and baptism date. Inside, there’s a simple silver cross necklace encased in a black velvet pouch. This keepsake is one your grandchild is sure to treasure for years to come. And since grandparents are famous for gifting money for lots of different occasions, you may want to tuck a check into the box as well.

Best from Godparents: Ocean Drop White Muslin Swaddle Blanket for Godchild

Are you a Godparent looking for a baby baptism gift? We’re obsessed with this amazing muslin blanket that gracefully displays the promise you’re making on their special day. It’s made of super soft and stretchy muslin material, much like the iconic Aden + Anais swaddle blankets, with bold black text that ensures baby will be wrapped in your abiding love on their baptism day and beyond.

Best Book: God Bless You and Good Night

If you are planning on giving a gift of money why not pair it with this sweet board book which reminds the baby in your life how much they are loved. Parents can read this at bedtime to their little one and watch as they grow to love it. For an added gift why not write a special inscription on the inside so they can treasure this book and message for years to come.

Best Art: Baby Animal Sheep

Decorate the nursery walls with an adorable baby sheep art print. You can customize the sizing and frame so it will fit right in with whatever their nursery scheme is.